Regarding the setup of the scoring system
Thread Content
Currently, the system has raised the requirements for scoring in sections for students above third grade in elementary school, but moderators still cannot score when browsing other sections. Could the forum consider changing this setting? Moderators should be able to score as moderators when managing their own sections, while also being able to score as regular members when viewing other sections (that is, scoring according to the grade determined by their moderator points). After all, moderators can’t just focus on their own sections; when they come across good content or discussions in other sections, they often feel helpless because they don’t have the permission to score. It’s really frustrating... Let’s discuss whether this is necessary; administrators should also take a look to see if it can be solved technically, and if so, resolve it as soon as possible.
I think this suggestion is very necessary. I’ve had this experience myself: when I see good posts on other sections, and because I do a lot of management work, I instinctively end up giving them extra points. But when it’s time to do so, I realize that I don’t have the authority to do it, which is quite disappointing. I hope my supervisor will consider this
I really understand this; I’m in the sample area, but I can’t rate the sections where I’m an expert, which is frustrating, and as a result I visit those areas less often
moderators of the HaiChuan limited edition are not allowed to rate content in forums that are not under their responsibility. The intention was to enable these moderators to manage their respective forums with high quality, but since most members have an interest in a wide range of topics, it’s inevitable that they will browse other content as well, and thus rating becomes necessary. So I think such restrictions should also be lifted; it makes sense both logically and emotionally! :victory:
There is a technical solution. One should not consider only the advantages; the disadvantages as well need to be taken into account. This can be discussed
Personally, I think moderators can give ratings in other sections, but there should be limits! A broken Plate scoring system – if that can be implemented, then our HaiChuan will truly be a pioneer in the forum industry!
Agree to conduct a trial run； Moderators put a lot of effort into managing their own forums, and it is believed that they will not disrupt the order in other forums as well. To be honest, those who post repeated ratings in other forums will have their scores reduced by 10 times. Then don’t comment.
It’s also okay to use ratings from other versions; just grant them the rating privileges of regular members, and no other settings are necessary. For nothing other than the grader to give the poster some recognition, that’s all.
It’s indeed a bit unreasonable to limit the scoring to this section only. My suggestion is to allow scoring across all sections; the moderators of each section in the industry technology exchange area can provide scores for the entire area.
Personally, I think it’s better for moderators to focus their main efforts on the forums they are in charge of. Although members who are at least in the third grade of elementary school and all team members can provide ratings across the entire forum, we should recognize that, compared to moderators, their amount of ratings and their rights to give ratings are limited. It is the moderators of each forum who truly play a decisive role in its development. The problem is that not all moderators have managed their forums well enough as to have more time to manage other forums; there are indeed such moderators, but they are in the minority. We certainly shouldn’t grant such privileges just because of these few people. It is suggested that such individuals consider taking on responsibility for several forums, but it’s better to refrain from granting them the right to provide ratings across the entire forum for now.
Moderators can’t give ratings across different regions? There’s such a rule? This is unreasonable and not good. A talented person cannot achieve success in only one area; therefore, such people should not be restricted from contributing in other fields as well. Trust our moderators and encourage widespread participation ； Of course, it is also necessary to restrict cross-region permissions; otherwise, everyone would become super moderators. Participation is a natural pleasure, and administrators cannot deprive people of this right, nor can moderators take it away from regular members. There’s no need to discuss this; once a rule is established, it should be followed.
It seems that this issue isn’t worth exploring in such depth... As a moderator, one is responsible for managing members, representing the forum’s approval or disapproval of them. Although ratings in other sections can be given by ordinary members, cross-disciplinary factors mean that such ratings cannot reflect true professionalism. Moreover, due to their special status, even though the ratings are given by ordinary members, it is still evident that they are moderators; therefore, it is recommended not to make this feature fully accessible to everyone. As bht11 said, the problem of an excess number of moderators can be addressed on a case-by-case basis.
Support for the jieg upgraded version can be tried out in specific sub-forums; if it is successful, it can then be implemented across the entire forum.
Support for suggestions regarding the upgraded version of Douban.
It would be better to consider the suggestion regarding the enhanced version of Douding: allowing users in non-administrator areas to score based on the points they have, thereby granting them rights equivalent to those of members at a certain level. It’s preferable not to enable scoring capabilities across all areas for now.
It would be better not to grant moderators the right to rate the entire forum for now; I still hope that moderators will focus their efforts on their own sections, as the management of many sections still needs improvement. For moderators who are eager to rate posts in other sections, this can be achieved through two methods: one is to send a request for rating posts to the moderator of that section, who will then carry out the rating on their behalf. Another option is to submit an application to the administrator to add extended users, such as team members, engineers, or instructors, but such applications go through strict evaluations, so the actual approval rate is not very high.