Share my personal experience on which is better, Magic Ear or VIPKid, and what the differences are
Thread Content
I’m considering enrolling my child in an English training course, and when I was looking for information, I saw parents on the internet sharing their suggestions regarding course choices. Some said that one-on-one tutoring with VIPKid is good for learning English, while others believed that small-group classes at Magic Ear are better. After trying these courses myself, I’d like to discuss which one is better between Magic Ear and VIPKid and what the differences are. The differences between Magic Ear and VIPKid lie in aspects such as the teaching method, content, and price. Magic Ear uses a small-group online teaching format, with foreign teachers from North America conducting the lessons; there are usually around four students per class. The curriculum is structured as follows: age 3 to 4 for phonics introduction, age 5 to 7 for semantic understanding, age 6 to 9 for literacy development, and age 9 to 12 for independent reading. The pricing for Magic Ear is determined based on the textbooks and course units; the cost varies depending on the learning stage. For the smaller package, which includes only 90 lessons, the price is 6,999 yuan, resulting in a unit price of 77 yuan per lesson. The current small package actually includes only 96 core lessons, at a price of 8,699 yuan. VIPKID, on the other hand, adopts a one-on-one teaching model with North American teachers; these teachers teach just one child, and the teaching materials can be adjusted as needed based on the child’s progress. However, the tuition fee for VIPKid one-on-one English lessons is around 150 to 200 yuan, with fees charged on a per-unit basis. The cost for 6 units of courses is 12,000 yuan, while the cost for 12 units is 24,000 yuan, which is a bit high. Which is better, Magic Ear or VIPKID? My opinion: In terms of their course systems and teaching staff, both Magic Ear and VIPKID are quite good. However, Magic Ear uses small class sizes of four students per teacher, with one foreign teacher teaching four students at the same time. Children can learn some basic English vocabulary, but they don’t get many opportunities to speak; the foreign teacher may not be able to pay attention to each child, especially since children have different levels of proficiency. VIPKID is a high-end service – there is no fixed foreign teacher for lessons, and parents need to make appointments themselves. The annual fee ranges from 20,000 to 40,000 yuan. For families with limited financial resources like mine, price is also an important factor to consider. So I researched many other online children’s English training institutions similar to Magic Ear and VIPKID. After comparing several of them, I chose an institution with a good reputation called Akaso Foreign Teacher Network, endorsed by Tong Dawei. This institution offers one-on-one lessons with real foreign teachers, with fixed teachers available, allowing children to learn English with foreign teachers at home every day, while also saving money. The cost for half a year is 4,099 yuan, and the annual fee is less than 6,988 yuan, with each lesson costing around 20 yuan on average. Here is the link to their free trial class: https://www.acadsoc.com.cn/vst/?id=175398. If you’re interested, you can try it out with your child. We signed up for their children’s English course, which includes 360 lessons per year at a cost of just under 7,000 yuan, which is within the financial capabilities of most families! The child has been studying for over half a year now, and the results have been quite good. I think Akaso matches students with dedicated teachers, which makes things much easier – learning progresses faster and progress can be seen clearly. Their teachers all hold internationally recognized teaching qualifications such as TEOSL. The class teacher reports on the student’s progress to parents on a weekly basis, and students can engage in one-on-one online lessons with foreign teachers every day; this helps keep the child’s interest in English alive and is also beneficial for their learning. Children receive a certificate after completing the course, which satisfies me greatly; it’s suitable for those who intend to study on a long-term basis
I took a look at the pricing systems of Magic Ear English and VIPKID. In fact, today’s online tutoring services offer the advantage of convenient class scheduling; moreover, their fees are lower than those of traditional offline tutoring centers. However, VIPKID English provides one-on-one lessons with teachers who are not fixed, and it is up to the parents to arrange meetings with these teachers, while Magic Ear English offers small group classes of four students each. The institution where my child is currently studying is: https://www.acadsoc.com.cn/vst/?id=179649. It also offers one-on-one video lessons with real foreign teachers online, and the tuition fees are much lower than those of Magic Ear English and VIPKID. My child, who initially found it difficult to speak, can now communicate fluently with the foreign teachers; I’m very satisfied with the results. Everyone should take a look and learn more about it
Both Magic Ear English and VIPKID are aimed at children aged 4 to 12, allowing them to be exposed to authentic English from an early age and thus laying a solid foundation for their future development. There is still a difference in the age range of children taught by Magic Ear English and VIPKID; the foundational levels of children in each group are different. Children have different levels of acceptance for English. Therefore, in order to provide better services for children’s learning, both Magic Ear English and VIPKID offer courses divided into several levels, allowing children to learn in a systematic manner right from the beginning of their English education*
Both Magic Ear English and VIPKID choose North American teachers for their foreign language instruction, and this is also the trend resulting from the gradual development of the market. After all, European and American foreign teachers are still widely recognized by parents in the market today. North American foreign teachers have pure English pronunciation, enabling children to receive proper training in spoken language. In addition to foreign teachers, Magic Ear also assigns a Chinese teacher to professionally correct children’s English pronunciation during their learning process, which is truly thorough and considerate. Of course, Magic Ear English and VIPKID also have very strict standards when selecting foreign teachers. Not only do these teachers need to possess strong abilities and qualifications, but they must also have sufficient teaching experience in order to ensure the overall quality of instruction and earn the approval of parents.
There are many English training institutions for children. It is crucial to choose a truly good one in order to achieve the best learning results. The reason why parents spend money to find such institutions for their children is that it is recommended to enroll them in institutions where both Chinese and foreign teachers are available for instruction. Initially, Chinese teachers can help with grammar and sentence structure, while foreign teachers can assist with listening and speaking skills
Which is better, Magic Ear or VIPKid? In terms of experience in online education and brand awareness, VIPKid is quite competitive in the K12 sector; many parents choose to enroll their children in VIPKid’s services. However, there is also a demand for small-group online classes. Each parent considers things from different perspectives, and both small-group classes and one-on-one tutoring have their advantages as well as their disadvantages. I think the decision ultimately depends on the child – it’s best to take the child to try out these options and compare them. Magic Ear focuses on small classes of 4 teachers from North America, offering programs for language development for children aged 3–4, semantic development for those aged 5–7, literacy development for children aged 6–9, and independent reading skills for children aged 9–12, all within an incremental learning system ； Vipkid specializes in one-on-one tutoring with foreign teachers in North America, offering 3 series of courses designed for all age groups from 3 to 18 years old, including English language arts courses, MC core courses, and comprehensive advanced courses ；
It is crucial to choose a good institution for children’s English learning; the quality of education provided is of utmost importance. Parents spend money on finding such institutions so that their children can truly acquire knowledge. Learning English online indeed makes things much more convenient. As for determining which website-based service is the best for children’s English learning, a simple search will reveal a wide variety of options: teachers from North America, elite Chinese teachers, peers of the same age, one-on-one VIP tutoring, small group classes of three students, paid services, free services, those that require regular attendance, programs listed on North American stock exchanges, those recommended based on word-of-mouth, and those with extensive advertising. To find an excellent English learning institution, it is recommended that you try out the free courses offered by those training agencies in person! Moreover, the class size shouldn’t be too large; a ratio of 1 to 4 or 6 is fine, but it’s best to have a one-to-one setup. With too many students, the teacher simply can’t take care of them all; they can only listen, and whether they learn well depends on the children themselves. Here is an article sharing a list of the top 10 online platforms for children’s English learning There is a comparison table that provides detailed information and analysis on aspects such as the teaching methods and pricing; the link to the article is: http://blog.doubng.cn. It might be very helpful to you. You can click to take a look; I hope it helps you