Comparing tooling valves and imported valves, which one (such as Fisher) is better?

The tooling valves are universal and popular and have very good results, but it is also good to use FISHER for valves with special applications, such as anti-surge valves, temperature reducing and pressure reducing valves. As for shut-off valves, imported FLOWSEWA and Mosonilan can be used in special occasions.

As a domestically produced valve, Wuxi Tooling is relatively good. Compared with foreign brands, it is still a bit inferior. Fisher, for example, is not in the same grade. When purchasing cut-off valves, it is best to decide whether an imported valve is needed based on process conditions.

For general applications, tooling is fine. For more severe working conditions, Fisher is better, but Masoneilan is mainly used in harsh working conditions.

KOSO is Corolla, Fisher is Cadillac:lol

Coincidentally, the production line of our installation uses two types of valves: Work clothes and fisher. The small-diameter regulating valve uses fisher, and the large-diameter butterfly valve and sleeve valve use tooling. First of all, consider the cost performance. The price of fisher valves with large diameter butterfly valves above DN400 is really too expensive. It is relatively unnecessary. The tooling 600S can meet the process needs. ； If you have higher sealing requirements, you can choose the 710E model (high price, long processing cycle) ； If you use fisher, the price is 10 times higher than the tool 710E of the same caliber (there was a quote from a dealer). For small diameters, we use Fisher’s valve positioner equipped with DVC2000. It is very easy to use and adjust. It is fully intelligent and only takes a few seconds to adjust. ； The current small-diameter valves installed in the tooling are equipped with Siemens valve positioners, which are relatively stable in operation and do not cause problems after long-term use. ； The rest depends on the delivery cycle and price comparison.

Tooling valves are more cost-effective than joint venture products； Original imported Fisher valves are basically high-end products and are expensive.

study* Yes, I want to ask a question: What does work clothes mean?

The name of a valve manufacturer in Wuxi is also called koso. In addition, cut-off valves are not Fisher’s specialty. Fisher mainly produces regulating valves.

The valves of the tooling are not on the same level as those of Fisher. I agree with the fifth floor and the tooling is JP’s technology. I don’t like it.

Wuxi Tooling is a wholly-owned company owned by JP. Its regulating valves are of good quality and can meet general working conditions. For small flow control valves, Meisok Nilan is the best. For cam deflection valves used under harsh working conditions, Meisok Nilan is also the best. FISHER regulating valves are of course very good, but they are too expensive. In terms of switch valves, they are not the best. Good brands include NELES, TYCO, FLOMSERVER, etc.

It should depend on the specific situation! The price of workwear is relatively cheaper, but FISHER's products have more advantages in terms of product performance, right?

There is no best, only suitable or inappropriate? Not any brand of valve is suitable for every project! QQ: 928976489

The valves made by Wuxi Tooling are good, equipped with KOSO positioners, which are easy to adjust and require little maintenance. If you consider the price, the imitation KOSO positioners from Changshu Chunxin are also acceptable. Haha, Fisher's ball valves have been used for many years and are almost maintenance-free.

Of course, the tooling valves cannot compare with Fisher's valves. But domestic products are relatively good.

Koso is okay in the country, but not in bad conditions. It can't be compared with Fisher.

In fact, several valve factories here in Wuxi are quite good, but KOSO has better control over the market.

Wuxi Tooling is considered to be the best in China. Many valve components are imported from Japan and assembled domestically. Fischer also has domestic factories that produce some low-end products, but the quality is just that. If they are imported, such as from Malaysia, the quality is more guaranteed. As for the on-off valve, it mainly depends on the ball valve seat material, hardness, and valve stem hardness. Some of the better ones include Flowserve, Tektronix, and Metso.

Koso is currently relatively poor in China, and is available in Wuxi, Anshan and other places! It was okay before, but the butterfly valve is better, slightly stronger than some domestic valves! At present, some sellers are serious about shoddy goods, which seriously ruins their reputation. Especially for electric valve amplifiers, damage is common! There is no comparison with European and American fisher, flowserve, masoneilan, etc.!

Koso is a Japanese brand, and strictly speaking it is considered an imported technology.

If you simply say "good", it must be fisher's. However, there is no best, only the most suitable. You should choose the most suitable valve according to your process requirements. Regarding the selection of shut-off valves, you should provide the valve manufacturer with the electrical requirements of the pipeline medium. Other details such as the minimum allowable leakage are also required. Then find a few more manufacturers to give you calculation books. You will understand after reading more.