Design issues in the analysis room of the design institute.
Thread Content
The design institute is working on the design for a methanol project for me; it only listed the tests that need to be conducted, but didn’t specify the testing equipment that needs to be purchased. As a result, I’m unable to issue a tender. Is it correct for the design institute to act in this way? I would appreciate some advice from those with more experience.
You can find analysis methods based on the analysis items, such as HG, GB, etc. The proprietary analysis methods specify requirements regarding the analysis principles, analysis steps and requirements, analysis reagents, preparation of indicators, analysis instruments, and analysis equipment. Regarding the bidding for analytical instruments: 1. No instrument manufacturer can fully meet all your requirements for analytical tasks; it is necessary to turn to different instrument distributors or manufacturers for purchases. 2. When purchasing analytical instruments and equipment, one should choose between domestic or imported models based on their financial situation; at the same time, other factors such as the ease of maintenance, stability, and convenience of use of the instruments must also be taken into consideration. The above suggestions are for reference only. Wishing you success in your work and the completion of the task at an early date.
1. What the design institute can provide you, that is, the design content it offers, is generally specified in detail in the contract; you can first consult the relevant contract. If there is, then the design institute is not following standards; if not, then your requirements are excessive. 2. If not, there are two scenarios: either you have your own factory or you plan to build one new one. If it is the former, there should be some layouts that can be shared: standard sample preparation rooms, large-scale instrument analysis rooms, high-temperature rooms, sample processing rooms, sample storage rooms, etc. If it’s a new factory, it’s necessary to take into account factors such as the size of the enterprise, the nature of the project, and the number of analysts planned to be employed. In any case, I hope you can explain your questions in more detail. 3. It is recommended that you go to the resource section to find materials related to laboratory construction standards; they are excellent resources. This post was last edited by Canghai Yili Sha on 2009-2-7 10:12.]
Please check the laboratory-related contents in the overall design and detailed design; there are specifications, SG‑050~053
The approach taken by the design firm is clearly incorrect; based on what the original poster said, since you commissioned the design firm to carry out the work, it must be engineering design. Even for the preliminary design, in accordance with the requirements of HG/T20688-2000 \"Specifications on the Depth of Content in Preliminary Design Documents for Chemical Plants\", it is necessary to provide design descriptions, a list of analysis items, a list of analysis equipment, an arrangement plan for the equipment in the central laboratory, as well as floor plans for the analysis rooms in the plants (workshops), etc. Therefore, if the design institute acts in this way and there are no specific provisions in your design contract, then such behavior on the part of the design institute is completely irresponsible.