Is it appropriate to set the red envelope this way?
Thread Content
【Red Packet Name】 500 Red Packets with Valid Stickers 【Start Time】 2008-12-31 12:47 【End Time】 2009-4-30 23:59 【Red Packet Distribution Type】 Random value 【Red Packet Value】 10–100 ¥ in wealth 【Maximum Number per Person】 1 【Total Number of Red Packets Available】 4568 remaining out of 5000 【Number of Red Packets Already Claimed】 432 【Red Packet Name】 1000 Red Packets with Valid Stickers 【Start Time】 2008-12-31 12:47 【End Time】 2009-4-30 23:59 【Red Packet Distribution Type】 Random value 【Red Packet Value】 1–199 ¥ in wealth 【Maximum Number per Person】 1 【Total Number of Red Packets Available】 4870 remaining out of 5000 【Number of Red Packets Already Claimed】 130 Opinions: 1. What is the purpose of distributing these red packets? I think it’s mainly to encourage more communication among everyone; everyone who posts hopes that their efforts will be recognized ； 2. It’s possible that posting 1,000 posts only earns 1 unit of wealth, while posting 500 posts earns at least 10 units of wealth; this contrast shows that it’s unreasonable ； 3. The large number of red envelope options available, coupled with the very small number of people who can receive them, indicates a problem with the way these options are structured ； 4. The amount of the red envelope is too flexible; it is suggested to set a fixed value, such as 100 for 500 posts and 200 for 1000 posts? 5. Why was the red envelope for primary school promotion canceled? This is the most important one, and it’s gone
If a pie falls from the sky, would one still complain that it’s not big enough?
I haven’t received any forum red envelopes for a long time. Are there still any red envelopes available in the forum? It seems there’s no longer a “Forum Wealth Center”! !
I agree with you; with such random red envelope distributions, unfortunate incidents can occur. I support setting a fixed value instead
Support the original poster – this isn’t some windfall; setting it to a fixed value is worth considering
Views on this: 1. What is the purpose of distributing red envelopes? I think it’s mainly to encourage more communication among everyone; everyone who posts hopes that their efforts will be recognized ； So it doesn’t matter whether to give a red envelope or not. This is the case for higher levels. 2. It’s possible that posting 1,000 posts only earns 1 unit of wealth, while posting 500 posts earns at least 10 units of wealth; this contrast shows that it’s unreasonable ； This is to encourage those of lower rank. People of high status don’t need such encouragement; they have plenty of wealth. 3. The large number of red envelope options available, coupled with the very small number of people who can receive them, indicates a problem with the way these options are structured ； There are indeed a few of the lower grades, so the higher grades are suitable. 4. The amount of the red envelope is too flexible; it is suggested to set a fixed value, such as 100 for 500 posts and 200 for 1000 posts? It doesn’t really matter, but it’s fine this way too. 5. Why was the red envelope for primary school promotion canceled? This is the most important one, yet it’s missing. Yeah, I completely agree – for elementary school students, red envelopes are really important.
It seems that the Fallautumn moderator didn’t properly understand the issue at hand. When members of our community raise questions, can a moderator really answer them in such a way? Everyone is concerned about these issues in order to help make HaiChuanZhiYou better. I agree with the in-depth analysis on floor 6. This pie is indeed difficult to get hold of, and sometimes it may not contain any filling at all, ^_^ It’s too hard for younger users to obtain this pie; even if they manage to get it, it might just be a crust with no filling. For the moderator’s reference. This post was last edited by 30dman on 2009-3-7 at 19:19.]
I agree with the original poster’s idea; the red envelopes should get larger as we move forward.
I agree with the original poster; the red envelope system needs to be reformed. The purpose of the small red envelopes is to boost Haiyous’ enthusiasm for participation and posting; generally, the higher the rank or the more posts one makes, the more wealth one earns, with a fixed value being preferable. Graduation red envelopes should not be abolished; instead, more other interesting red envelopes should be added. Just like with the daily small red envelopes, the wealth amount on weekends should also be a bit higher. The above suggestions are provided for the reference of moderators and site administrators.
The original poster has put forward suggestions from the perspectives of rationality and fairness, and I support them.
In my opinion, when setting up red envelopes, more consideration should be given to new users; it’s better to encourage them more! Of course, it is undeniable that old members have made many contributions to the forum. I suggest adding banking features! Don’t set the interest rate too high!
Absolute fairness is unattainable, as there are many uncertainties in life. By following the steps outlined in the post about how to upgrade, you can earn more wealth and definitely upgrade faster.
People who are rich won’t care about such a small amount of wealth: lol
Post more replies, create more topics – someone will give ratings. The red envelopes are merely symbolic in terms of value
Regarding the poster’s question about the red envelopes for primary school students: The maintenance staff has already explained that it was due to technical flaws in the system related to these red envelopes that allowed them to be collected multiple times. That’s why they have been temporarily disabled. Please understand this. If you have any good suggestions, you can post them or contact the maintenance staff directly
Yes, I keep collecting them every day to bring a bit of good fortune
The starting threshold is too high; for example, the requirements for second graders and third graders are quite stringent, and it’s necessary to increase the standards step by step