Thread Content
The most alarming gap between China and Japan and Germany is truly disheartening. First of all, I must say that China’s manufacturing industry is underdeveloped. I study mechanical manufacturing, so I’d like to share some of my experiences. When I and the technicians at the factory worked day and night to improve the precision of the CNC machine tools, translating German documents in the process, when I went through countless difficulties without any vacation or overtime pay, covered in dirt with injuries all over my hands, and failed many times during the testing process – until finally I managed to produce a sample with precision meeting the required level of 0.0001 millimeters for the first time – I felt excited for a while, but then I felt disappointed, because the CNC machine tool in question was made in Germany; its control computer system was German-made, the processing software was also German-made, and even the cutting tools and drills were Japanese-made! Apart from the factory buildings, not a single tool is made in China! Even the factory buildings were designed with reference to foreign experiences. Fellow countrymen, those of you who are not involved in this work may not have a deep understanding of it. To manufacture a part with an accuracy of 0.0001 millimeters, the tools required are those made abroad, and the precision of these tools is several times, or even dozens of times or hundreds of times, higher than that of the product itself! A small drill bit used for high-precision machining – we simply can’t make that! It costs several thousand yen for the Japanese one! There’s nothing I can do. Don’t get complacent just because you know some fashion software like Photoshop; a full set of legitimate RO/E software costs nearly 80 million yuan! I’m giving it to you, but you can’t even install it, let alone use it. What’s the difference? A few years ago, when we were in college, we watched the news in the hall of our school; representatives from each department were there. When the TV showed that Japanese university students had created a robot that was taken to Germany to compete with robots made by German university students, the students from our mechanical engineering department were stunned. That robot was the kind that can walk on its own by maintaining balance on both feet, but it didn’t have any outer shell. Those of us in this field could immediately see the controllers, motors, and wires all over its body. The camera showed the robot performing actions on its own – doing backflips with its hands, bowing at 90 degrees, and jumping forward with its feet. Students and teachers from other departments smiled and said, “It’s so fun and adorable!” But while we were surprised, we also felt genuine… fear! The real fear is that the gap is simply too large; these are the achievements of manufacturing, automatic control, and materials science. I hate Japan, and that’s why I’m afraid. Laypeople don’t realize just how large this gap is. Let me put it this way: if a war breaks out and China’s manufacturing industry still has such a significant gap compared to other countries, then you and I will be forced to fight with nothing but guns and rifles. This isn’t an exaggeration; although we can engage in reverse engineering, it’s similar to Taiwan buying weapons when the mainland produces its own weapons – it’s not useful at all. It seems that society these days places increasing emphasis on industries that do not play a crucial role in the country’s economy and people’s well-being – things like real estate development, computers, software, and business. It’s fine to succeed in these areas, but when a few people drive up housing prices even further, such ways of making money are nothing to be proud of, I tell you! To put it simply, it’s immoral! Computers have become widespread, but how much do we really know about core manufacturing technologies? Not to mention software – there are many hackers, and yet that software is both good and cheap. How can you compete? There are too many people who work with computers! Don’t think that all science fiction movies are true; in reality, computers don’t fight battles – it’s machines that are actually involved! The gap between computers isn’t that big. In a battle, when missiles miss their targets or stop working, and tanks break down, there’s still me, you, and everyone else – we’ll have to charge forward with swords. I don’t want to do that; what about you? Don’t get dizzy at the sight of fancy cars. Leaving aside the question of what kind of value those girls in their early 20s have to offer in order to afford modified Hummer SUVs, if we look into the past, how many wealthy people in China didn’t build their fortunes through illegal means? And how many of them can claim that they didn’t act against their conscience? The richer and more capable one is, the greater the responsibility to contribute to the people. Look at the current situation in China: how many wealthy people prefer to buy cars manufactured using technology from ten years ago in Japan just to show off in front of their fellow citizens, rather than investing their money in society – after all, what comes from the people should go back to the people Do foreigners go out of their way to show kindness whenever there’s a flood disaster? They have their reasons; they don’t compare the quality of foreigners with that of their own people, and in fact they consider the quality of their own citizens to be low. Whenever I see foreign cars, I feel guilty and sorry for everyone, because I work in the manufacturing industry; yet I know that it’s already difficult in our country to achieve precise surface finishing on car bodies, let alone develop engines. Grow up already, wake up! Stop being obsessed with the fact that GDP has risen again. Look at the quality of the products we produce – it’s heartbreaking! Stop acting like ignorant children by constantly staring at sports cars, and stop showing off foreign-made digital products such as ultra-thin portable players – those are technologies that have been phased out. The backbone of any country is its manufacturing industry! Over the past 200 years, I don’t know what the future holds; in any case, the current situation won’t change. Don’t think that being able to make money makes one skilled or worthy of pride. When someone boasts about how many luxury cars they’ve seen, how many properties they’ve sold, how many web pages they’ve designed, or who they’ve gotten signatures from, I admit those are the results of their hard work, but I dismiss them as unimportant. I judge a person’s abilities based on whether they truly create real value for society, whether they genuinely improve productivity. Although I spend my days working with cold machines, using complex 3D design software to create drawings late into the night, and my monthly salary is only 1,500 yuan, wearing outdated clothes that aren’t in line with fashion trends and not knowing who’s popular these days, I still take the bus to work. But when asked about my situation, I’ll tell them everything without hesitation, regardless of how they look down on me. Because I work in mechanical manufacturing and automation; as a worker, as someone who strives to ensure that missiles are accurate and high-quality, and that tank engines are unparalleled, I feel proud – even though my salary is only 1,500 yuan.
Wow, that’s really insightful – it helps the Chinese people understand what the gaps are and where efforts should be focused for national advancement; only by creating world-class products can there be hope.
The differences go beyond these; what’s crucial are the systems and culture. Our systems fail to enable the best talents to give their best performance, and that is the biggest problem! Talents are lost, mediocre people come to power, and in turn they exclude those with talent! There is no awareness of the crisis at all; it seems like a time of peace and prosperity. To borrow a line from a poem: The warm breeze intoxicates the visitors, making them think Hangzhou is Bianzhou. It’s rare to find someone with the insight of the original poster!
Talents are lost, mediocre people come to power, and in turn they exclude those with talent! Perspicacious! Without the right decisions, it’s like an army without a leader or a car without a driver; it loses its purpose and forgets the truth. I’m truly saddened by China’s current situation!
That is indeed the case; the people of this country must strive to strengthen themselves!
The original poster has put it very profoundly, prompting the Chinese people to reflect. **In recent years, there has been increasing pressure to pursue this direction, but few people in domestic universities and the Chinese Academy of Sciences are actually engaged in genuine research
Manufacturing is the foundation of other industries; if manufacturing performs poorly, it has a direct impact on other sectors, especially those in the military and high-precision industries; Perhaps we should see the gap and strive to catch up ; At the same time, education is the foundation of all foundations; if education suffers cuts, one can only imagine the consequences
The original poster has said something very profound; the Chinese people indeed need to reflect on themselves.
"Self-improvement"----Strive for strength **!
This is the consequence of having no industrial manufacturing foundation and instead pursuing the idea that \"whatever cat it is, as long as it can catch mice, it’s a good cat.\" ” I have thought about this issue for a long time. For any machine, such as the equipment used in our chemical processing industries, even if the manufacturing gap compared to foreign products is 99%, it’s still only 99%. Naturally, the final product will have a quality level of 0.99*0.99*0.99*0.99=. . . . With the same process and the same equipment, the products turn out different. . Sigh~~~
Manufacturing technology is developed gradually; it’s impossible to achieve success overnight. Keep going!
Due to historical reasons, they are behind, but the Chinese are intelligent and will eventually catch up with foreign countries. :lol
China’s low level of machine tool manufacturing determines the level of processing in its machining industry. Take SHENGU, which represents the level of blowers in China – it was even made into a TV drama starring Mei Ting. It’s not even on the same level as Germany’s; we truly feel utterly overwhelmed. It’s still caused by China’s systemic problems.
The key issue is **the policies in place**; these days, those working in technology are not as valued as officials. Many people in the technical field, once they become famous, become some kind of representative or committee member, and thus no longer have the inclination to continue working on research
Support, absolute support! 1. China’s basic national conditions determine that we are simply unable to change our current situation for the time being; they constrain our thoughts and destiny. 2. Only when there are those who can recognize talent does a horse of outstanding ability come into existence ; There are often fine horses, but not many people who can recognize their worth. In fact, China has many talented people – why do they all go abroad? . . . . . Reflection! Reflect!
There is still a long way to go in terms of improving the capabilities of upstream enterprises and advancing cutting-edge technology; in our country, there are not only these gaps, but many more that remain unfilled. I think what the original poster said can be used as an example: promote it more in universities, and even start promoting it from elementary school. **Technology is needed, and students need a sense of mission.
Only by improving the system can a healthy national culture be developed, and it is only with such a culture that the impetuous societal tendency to focus on money can be eliminated. Only then can the intelligent Chinese people become truly wise
What the original poster said is great. I have been to Japan and Germany; China is smarter than them, but it doesn’t use that intelligence in the right way. And if it were used in the right way, people wouldn’t be considered good. The Japanese and Germans are more diligent in their work than we are, but what’s the use of being diligent?