HCBBS Forum (English)
Submit Chemical Projects / Find Solutions
Amplify Your Requirements on a Broader Chemical Platform *Engineering · Technology · Equipment · Solutions*
Submit Request

The current status of vanadium extraction from lignite in our country

2010-10-24View Original

Thread Content

This post was last edited by x178181454 on 2010-10-30 at 20:27. The extraction of vanadium from lignite in our country has been an activity going on for several decades, yet the entire industry remains quite backward. Current enterprises involved in this process face high costs and low recovery rates, making it very difficult for them to survive. Analyzing the reasons, there are mainly three: 1. **Insufficient investment in this industry. 2. Most corporate investors have many misconceptions about the vanadium extraction industry from stone coal. 3. Many processing technologies are substandard. I. **Insufficient investment in this industry.** Due to insufficient investment in this industry, a complete theory for vanadium extraction from lignite has not been developed. Many technicians have only a superficial understanding of vanadium extraction from lignite, and no complete system has been established. II. Most corporate investors have many misconceptions about the vanadium extraction industry from stone coal. Misconception 1: The vanadium industry is a highly polluting industry. People assume that vanadium production is a highly polluting process, especially when sodium-based methods are used; however, this is not the case. The main pollutants generated in the sodium process are hydrogen chloride and sulfur dioxide gases produced during roasting; these two gases are easy to treat and their treatment costs are low. There are no toxic or harmful components in the waste residues and wastewater, as evidenced by the long-term use of lignite as an admixture in cement production. Why do people form wrong perceptions? It is because many small, home-based factories do not treat their exhaust gases; hydrogen chloride and sulfur dioxide are released directly into the air, where they form hydrochloric acid and sulfurous acid, which can kill the plants in the surrounding area. Error 2: Vanadium is an industry with huge profits. Extracting vanadium from lignite is not at all profitable, and only very few companies are able to make a profit from it. Why? The reason is as follows: 1. The price of vanadium has remained low for a long time; over the 25-year period from 1986 to 2010, there were only three periods of high prices (160,000 yuan per ton in June and July 1989, 350,000 yuan per ton from April to June 2005, and 280,000 yuan per ton in July and August 2008), and these periods lasted very briefly. For the most part, prices remained low; before 1989, the price of vanadium was 40,000–50,000 yuan per ton, from 1990 to 2004 it was 30,000–50,000 yuan per ton, and from 2006 to 2010 the price of vanadium was 70,000–100,000 yuan per ton. 2. Vanadium recovery rates are generally low and costs are high in lignite-based vanadium extraction enterprises. Typically, vanadium recovery rates in lignite-based vanadium extraction enterprises are only around 40%, with costs of about 100,000 yuan per ton, making production unfeasible. 3. The leading companies in China’s vanadium industry, Panzhihua and Chengde, have high production volumes (around 30,000 tons per year) and low costs (the project cost is no more than 60,000 yuan per ton). The two families jointly established a vanadium trading company whose annual trade volume accounts for around 20% of the world’s total, giving it significant influence over international vanadium prices. It holds the power to set prices domestically; when demand is high, they drive up vanadium prices, and when demand is low, they drive them down. Error 3: Extracting vanadium from lignite is simple. Many people think that extracting vanadium from lignite is easy and that it can be done as long as there is enough money; in reality, however, it is very difficult. Lignite contains only about 1% vanadium, with 99% being impurities, and it is quite challenging to achieve a vanadium content of 98% in the final product. Competition with Panzhihua and Chengde, which use steel slag to extract vanadium (with 10-20% vanadium content in the steel slag), makes things even more difficult. In 2005, the price of vanadium rose to around 350,000 yuan, leading to the construction of many large-scale producers of vanadium from lignite in China. Nowadays, most of these facilities are unable to operate properly and are facing great difficulties. Error 4: Possessing lignite resources equates to wealth. Lignite (containing vanadium) is extremely abundant in China; it can be found from Zhejiang in the east to Xinjiang in the west, from the Gobi Desert in the north to Guangxi in the south, with deposits present in more than a dozen provinces across the country. Since lignite contains only 1% vanadium, its commercial value is limited; profitability is possible only by establishing integrated enterprises for mining, processing, and smelting at the source site. III. Many processing technologies are inadequate. The technologies for extracting vanadium from lignite generally originate from research institutions or from the technical staff of existing enterprises that specialize in this process. Research institutions generally focus on laboratory techniques, and there is still a distance to go before these can be applied in industrial production ; Old vitriol extraction enterprises from lignite generally use traditional methods for production; their technical staff lack the ability to innovate, making it impossible to establish a more advanced enterprise for extracting vanadium from lignite. I am willing to discuss this with vanadium extraction enterprises and technical personnel in the whole country. Mao Hua 13227415138
Reply #22011-01-25
I’m also somewhat connected to this industry, and after reading the original poster’s article, I found the summary to be very accurate; many of the points expressed align with my own views. I hope we’ll have the opportunity to exchange more ideas in the future.
Reply #32011-02-24
The original poster has done a great analysis, very objective! However, there is a different perspective on one point: although leading companies such as Panzhihua Iron and Steel and Chengde Iron and Steel have high vanadium production volumes and low costs, this should not mean that other vanadium production industries have no future. I think it should be analyzed in this way: Pansteel and Chenggang are not merely vanadium-producing enterprises; vanadium is just a by-product. But which steelmaking company would dare to use low-quality iron ore? Many people are aware of how high the grade of vanadium-titanium magnetite is. So even if the cost of vanadium extraction is low, it still needs to be sold at a high price to offset other unprofitable aspects. To change the current situation, efforts must be made in terms of technology, and there is still a long way to go.
Reply #42011-05-13
Are the three peak periods for vanadium prices equivalent to the price of elemental vanadium?
Reply #52011-05-19
I work in the extraction of vanadium from lignite as well; the original poster’s words are very apt! !
Reply #62019-09-03
The leaching solution in the sodium-based process for vanadium extraction from lignite contains a large amount of chloride ions, and the concentration of these ions has a significant impact on the adsorption efficiency. As a result, it is not possible to recycle the leaching solution, which generates large amounts of wastewater that are difficult to treat. The new vanadium extraction process using lignite in our company has the following advantages: First, it is not a sodium-based process; the leaching solution contains almost no chloride ions. This allows for the recycling of the leaching solution after separation, resulting in no wastewater generation. II. Since this new technology contains almost no chlorine, there is no chlorine gas in the roasting flue gases; as a result, there is no need to use sodium hydroxide spraying for chlorine removal, which saves a significant amount of cost associated with flue gas treatment. III. The comprehensive vanadium recovery rate reaches as high as 85%, which is 15%~20% higher than that of the conventional sodium method. Due to the low costs of wastewater and flue gas treatment, as well as a high comprehensive recovery rate for vanadium, the production cost of vanadium pentoxide is significantly reduced. On-site visits and inquiries are welcome. Phone: 15927251658, QQ: 442781803

Submit a Project

**Looking for Chemical Technology, Equipment & Solutions?** No Registration Required Broader Platform Exposure | Global Chemical Service Provider Connections

Submit Request — Free Consultation

Disclaimer

This is an automated machine translation of the original thread. Some technical terms may have inaccuracies; the original text shall prevail. Click "View Original" at the top right to access the source page, which supports IP-based automatic real-time language translation. Please watch out for contact details and sales inducements to prevent fraud. All content and translations are for reference only, representing solely the poster's personal views. For enquiries, email service@hcbbs.com.