There should be some mandatory measures to have the beneficiaries rate
Thread Content
Some users who sign up come specifically looking for solutions; once they get a satisfactory response, they leave. Some questions from netizens at sea received very specific and detailed quantitative answers, without even a single score. This is not conducive to the development of the forum; management should give them appropriate warnings or punishments.
Helping others solve problems is also a major feature of Haichuan. Regarding the situation where those who seek help receive the answers without any evaluation, I believe that: 1. The forum administrators should provide some form of reward to those who give answers. 2. A kind reminder to the person seeking help is sufficient; there’s no need for punishment. After all, our goal is to help others and support one another. 3. Provide appropriate guidance to the person seeking help.
There should be some mandatory measures to have the beneficiaries rate. Spare the punishment.
“The “penalty” is mild, such as point deductions, rather than arresting people. I may not have explained myself clearly; I’m sorry.
Agreed~ Take a look at each section – there are very few ratings given by people who aren’t moderators. Moderators spend most of their time on rating tasks, and this isn’t a good sign~
This post was last edited by wiseboy on 2011-4-1 15:39. Seeking only without giving anything back is not the right attitude. Over time, I’m worried that there will be fewer and fewer opportunities to help others.
Reply to 6# wiseboy: Most users who register to ask for help are beginners; how should they be punished? Deduction? This will lead to two outcomes: 1) they will no longer visit that forum, or 2) they will register again under a different alias. Besides, beginners don’t give high ratings either; their rank is right there to show it. You can’t block IDs, right? What will happen to the reputation of that forum then? In some companies’ local networks, one ID is used by N people; blocking that ID will affect many innocent users as well. I think there is a process to attracting netizens to participate in the forum; one shouldn’t rush, let alone think about imposing any punishments. As a legitimate forum with a strong academic atmosphere, those who belong here will eventually show up; just as the waves sift out the sand, isn’t that exactly what happens to us? Additionally: Our veteran users, especially those in management positions, should be more tolerant; the key is to help new users get familiar with the forum rules. We need to live up to the HaiChuan brand, adjust our mindset, and commit ourselves. Feel free to communicate.
What everyone is saying is the actual situation.
Suddenly I had a new idea: I wonder if it’s possible to hide the content of posts while keeping the ratings visible!
This post was last edited by wiseboy on 2011-4-8 17:13: “I suddenly had a new idea – I wonder if it’s possible to hide the content of posts while keeping the ratings visible!” ” This is not difficult to achieve technically; it is estimated that with some minor modifications, HaiChuan can make this possible.
I strongly support this view and strongly condemn those who turn a blind eye when others help you.