If Sun Bin had died 10 years later, Bai Qi would have faced Sun Bin in a fight – who would have won? ?
Thread Content
Sun Bin: Achievements of Sun Bin: The horse racing match between Tian Ji and others, the strategy of encircling Wei to rescue Zhao, increasing troops while reducing cooking fires, pretending to be foolish or using deception (when facing Pang Juan), and ultimately defeating Pang Juan, thereby enabling King Wei of Qi to become a dominant ruler in his region. By leaving behind the \"Art of War\" by Sun Bin, he was a master with both solid theoretical knowledge and practical skills; truly a great genius. Bai Qi: In the battles of Yique and Changping, he led the Qin army in campaigns against Han, Wei, Zhao, Chu, and other states, achieving victory after victory and enabling Qin to acquire vast territories. He made outstanding contributions to the State of Qin’s unification of China and was the top general of the Qin army. If they met and had a fight, who do you think would win? ?
Sun Bin, right? In those times, winning battles didn’t depend solely on weapons; I think Sun Bin had a better chance of winning!
One is a general and the other is a military advisor; they are not at the same rank, so such an assumption is basically invalid.
Generally, knowing yourself and your opponent ensures victory in every battle; if these two people don’t know each other, from which aspects should they start making comparisons?
Reply to 1# xya8: In a battle between Guan Gong and Qin Qiong, I think Jiang Ziya would win.
Reply to 1# xya8: In a battle between Guan Gong and Qin Qiong, I think Jiang Ziya would win. Hahahahaha, that’s so creative!
Even if it’s true, it’s definitely Bai Qi who will win. The rise of the Qin state was a strategic ascent, driven by its overall strength and that of its army; Sun Bin, on the other hand, was only an expert in tactics, capable of managing individual cities or regions. When Qin conquered the six states, it was not a matter of fighting over individual cities or territories; it was years of continuous warfare and conflict, as well as a long-term struggle against economic power.
The team plays the most important role; the more united and cooperative a team is, the greater its chances of winning.
Someone upstairs has already answered; Jiang Ziya will win.
No one was fighting with knives; surely Bai Qi was the more skilled one, taking command from the front – only heaven knows.