HCBBS Forum (English)
Submit Chemical Projects / Find Solutions
Amplify Your Requirements on a Broader Chemical Platform *Engineering · Technology · Equipment · Solutions*
Submit Request

Advantages and disadvantages of horizontal vibrating screens and inclined vibrating screens

2023-11-18View Original

Thread Content

Horizontal vibrating screens and inclined vibrating screens operate by utilizing the reciprocating rotary vibration generated by vibrators. The upper rotating weight of the vibrator causes the screen surface to undergo planar rotational vibration, while the lower rotating weight induces conical rotational vibration on the screen surface; the combined effect of these two results in complex rotational vibration of the screen surface. Its vibration trajectory is a complex spatial curve. The projection of this curve on the horizontal plane is circular, while its projection on the vertical plane is elliptical. Adjusting the excitation force of the upper and lower rotating weights can change the amplitude. Adjusting the spatial phase angles of the upper and lower weights can change the curvature of the motion trajectory of the screen surface, as well as the motion path of the materials on the screen surface. So, what are the advantages and disadvantages of horizontal vibrating screens and inclined vibrating screens? Introduction to horizontal vibration screens: Horizontal vibration screens are those that move along an elliptical path; they feature high efficiency, high screening precision, and a wide range of applicable scenarios. Compared to ordinary screens of the same specification, it has a larger processing capacity and higher screening efficiency. Suitable for solvents in the metallurgical industry, the screening of cold-sintered ore, ore grading in the mining industry, as well as grading, dewatering, and desliming operations in the coal industry. It is an ideal alternative to existing large-scale vibrating screens and products imported from abroad. Horizontal vibrating screens are widely used in quarrying and the screening of sand and gravel materials. They can also be employed in coal sorting, mineral processing, the construction materials industry, construction, and the power and chemical industries for the grading of products. Separation principle of horizontal vibrating screen: Power is transmitted from the motor via a V-belt to the drive shaft of the vibrator, as well as to the gear vibrator (with a speed ratio of 1), enabling the three shafts to rotate at the same speed and thus generating excitation force. The vibrator is connected to the screen frame through high-strength bolts, which results in an elliptical motion. The material moves rapidly in an elliptical motion on the screen surface as the screener operates, allowing for rapid stratification, screening, and movement forward, thereby completing the grading of the material. Introduction to inclined vibrating screens: The circular motion of inclined vibrating screens makes them a new type of efficient vibrating screen with multiple layers. Circular vibrating screens use a barrel-type eccentric shaft exciter along with offset blocks to adjust the amplitude. They feature a long material screening path and a wide range of screening specifications. They boast reliable structure, strong excitation force, high screening efficiency, low vibration noise, durability, ease of maintenance, and safety in use. Circular vibrating screens are widely applied in product grading across industries such as mining, building materials, transportation, energy, and chemicals. Depending on the material products and user requirements, high-manganese steel woven screens, perforated screen plates, and rubber screen plates can be used. The screen plates are available in single-layer and double-layer versions, and all types can meet various requirements regarding screening performance. These circular vibrating screens are installed in a seated configuration. The adjustment of the screen surface inclination can be achieved by changing the height of the spring support position. The screening process for horizontal vibrating screens and inclined vibrating screens is the same: it involves passing a mixture of materials with different particle sizes multiple times through a single-layer or multi-layer screen surface with evenly distributed holes, thereby separating them into various size categories – this process is what is known as screening. Particles larger than the sieve holes remain on the surface of the sieve and are referred to as the oversize material for that sieve surface, while particles smaller than the sieve holes pass through them and are called the undersize material for that sieve surface. The actual screening process is as follows: when a large amount of fragmented material with various particle sizes and mixed coarseness enters the screen surface, only some of the particles come into contact with it. Due to the vibration of the screen box, the layer of material on the screen becomes loosened, further widening the gaps that already exist between the larger particles. The smaller particles then take this opportunity to pass through these gaps and move to the lower layer or onto the conveyor. Due to the small gaps between the small particles, the larger particles cannot pass through them; as a result, the originally disordered cluster of particles separates itself, layering itself by size – with the small particles at the bottom and the larger particles on top. The fine particles that reach the sieve surface and are smaller than the sieve pores pass through the sieve, thereby achieving the separation of coarse and fine particles and completing the screening process. However, perfect separation does not occur; during screening, generally a certain amount of undersize material remains in the oversize fraction. When fine particles pass through a sieve, although all of them are smaller than the sieve openings, their ease of passage varies. Particles whose size is similar to that of the sieve openings have difficulty passing through; it becomes even more difficult for them to pass through the gaps between the particles on the lower layer of the sieve surface. Advantages of horizontal vibrating screens: 1. Horizontal vibrating screens come in various configurations and have multiple functions. It is suitable for horizontal and low-inclination installations, which allows **reducing the height of the belt conveyor equipment, providing more space for the feeder, and lowering the overall installation height of the equipment. 2. The horizontal vibrating screen is driven by an Eliptex exciter. The uniquely designed Eliptex vibrator enables the vibrating screen to move in three directions: horizontal, vertical, and elliptical motion. This **increases the screening capacity and speed while ensuring proper product sizing.** The HRI horizontal vibrating screen can be used for the screening and sorting of various materials. 3. Horizontal vibrating screens come in various configurations and have multiple functions. It is suitable for horizontal and low-inclination installations, which allows **reducing the height of the belt conveyor equipment, providing more space for the feeder, and lowering the overall installation height of the equipment. 4. The horizontal vibrating screen is driven by an Eliptex exciter. The uniquely designed Eliptex vibrator enables the vibrating screen to move in three directions: horizontal, vertical, and elliptical motion. This **increases the screening capacity and speed while ensuring proper product sizing.** The HRI horizontal vibrating screen can be used for the screening and sorting of various materials. Screen the output and speed, and ensure the product particle size. The HRI horizontal vibrating screen can be used for the screening and sorting of various materials. Advantages of inclined vibrating screens: 1. In the fields of screening and crushing, inclined vibrating screens have become a worldwide industry standard, and are widely used in industries such as coal mines, metal mines, quarries, cement plants, and steel mills. It is favored by many customers for its unparalleled reliability, high productivity, low consumption and easy maintenance, as well as long service life. 2. Equipped with Vibrex exciters, unique to inclined vibratory screens, on vibratory screens with a width of up to 2.7 meters, this design ensures that the equipment requires only minimal maintenance and can operate continuously for many years. 3. The product specifications for inclined vibrating screens range from 1.25x3.0 meters to 2.4x9.6 meters, and they can be equipped with single-layer or multi-layer screening units. 4. A design that follows industry trends, with a long service life ; It performs exceptionally well even in the most complex environments. Now, inclined vibrating screens are available all over the world. Disadvantages of inclined vibrating screens: 1) Clogged sieve pores – When the feed contains high levels of mud or moisture, it can cause the material to stick to the sieve pores, blocking them. At this time, the sieve holes should be cleaned, and then the water spray volume and the inclination angle of the sieve surface should be adjusted appropriately. 2) Severe wear of screen holes: When the screen mesh of an inclined vibrating screen is used for a long time, it can lead to severe wear of the screen holes, which significantly affects the screening efficiency. At this point, the worn sieve holes should be repaired; when the wear is severe, replacing the sieve mesh should be considered. 3) Uneven feeding by the sieve: If the feeding chute of an inclined vibrating sieve is too narrow, the material cannot be distributed evenly across the entire sieve surface. This prevents the sieve surface from being utilized effectively, thereby affecting the screening efficiency. At this point, the width of the feed chute should be adjusted to ensure uniform feeding to the sieve. 4) Excessively thick material on the sieve surface: An excessively thick layer of material on the inclined vibrating sieve can be caused by an increased feeding rate, blocked sieve pores, or a low inclination angle of the sieve surface. At this point, adjustments should be made according to the specific circumstances. 5) Insufficient inclination angle of the screen surface: The most common reason for poor screening performance in inclined vibrating screens is an insufficient inclination angle of the screen surface. To address this, it is necessary to raise the rear support base. In practice, an inclination angle of 20° for the screen surface is considered appropriate. Generally, the optimal inclination angle range for circular vibrating screens is 16–20°. If the angle falls below 16°, problems such as poor material flow along the screen surface or materials rolling upward may occur. 6) The movement directions of the eccentric blocks are not in phase. Poor screening performance in inclined vibrating screens may be related to the movement directions of these eccentric blocks; two sets of eccentric blocks with equal mass are required to rotate in opposite directions in a self-synchronized manner, thereby generating a single excitation force that acts along the vibration direction at a fixed angle relative to the horizontal direction, causing the screen box to move back and forth in a straight line. If they are not in the same phase, the direction of the excitation force will not coincide with the direction of vibration, thus failing to achieve efficient screening. Images: Horizontal vibrating screens have advantages over inclined vibrating screens: First, due to their horizontal installation, they require less space, making them the preferred screening equipment in crushing and sand-making production lines. Of course, this depends on its operational advantages. The motion trajectory of a horizontal three-axis elliptical vibrating screen is elliptical in shape. Its designed vibration frequency, amplitude, and vibration direction angle can all be adjusted according to actual usage requirements, so as to achieve the desired screening efficiency and processing capacity. II. The horizontal vibration screen combines the advantages of both inclined circular vibration screens and horizontal linear vibration screens. It features horizontal installation, low space occupation on site, good screening efficiency, high processing capacity, and a low installation height, making it an ideal device for various mines, quarry sites, and mobile screening stations. III. The motor of the horizontal vibrating screen drives a gearbox-type synchronizer via a drive belt, thereby forcing the synchronization of the three shafts. The middle shaft rotates in the opposite direction to the two side shafts, thereby driving three sets of block-eccentric vibrators that are mounted on the frame of the screening box. The motion trajectory of the screening box is elliptical, and the motor can be installed on the left or right side. IV. The horizontal vibration screen is installed horizontally, occupying little space on site. It consists of a motor, a transmission mechanism, a screening box, rubber springs, a base frame, dampers, and other components. As an upgraded version of the circular vibration screening machine, when this device is in operation, power is transmitted from the motor via a V-belt to the drive shaft of the exciter and the gear vibrator (with a speed ratio of 1), enabling the three shafts to rotate at the same speed and thus generating excitation force. The exciter is connected to the screening box through high-strength bolts, which results in an elliptical motion. The material moves rapidly in an elliptical motion on the screen surface as the screener operates, allowing for rapid stratification, screening, and movement forward, thereby completing the grading of the material. The horizontal vibration screen is installed horizontally, occupying less space on site. Its operating advantages are as follows: 1. High processing capacity and high screening efficiency ; 2. The operating trajectory of the screener is elliptical; it operates smoothly with low power consumption ; 3. The dual amplitude (15–19 mm), vibration direction angle (30°–60°), and vibration frequency (645–875 r/min) are adjustable, offering easy and straightforward adjustment ; 4. The material screening operates smoothly; it is not prone to clogged holes or material blockages. Image 5: With the same screening area as inclined vibrating screens, the throughput of horizontal vibrating screens can be increased by 1.3 to 2 times ; Three-axis drive enables the screen to perform ideal elliptical motion, combining the advantages of circular vibration screens and linear vibration screens. The elliptical trajectory as well as the amplitude can be adjusted, allowing the choice of vibration pattern based on the properties of the material being screened; this is particularly advantageous for materials that are difficult to separate ; Three-axis driven forced synchronous excitation enables the screening machine to achieve a stable operating state, which is particularly advantageous for screening tasks that require high processing capacities ; At the same time, this device improves the stress conditions on the sieve frame, reduces the load on individual bearings, ensures even stress distribution across the side plates, minimizes stress concentration points, and enhances the stress conditions of the sieve frame. As a result, it increases the reliability and lifespan of the screening machine, providing a theoretical basis for the enlargement of such machines ; Due to its horizontal installation, it effectively reduces the height of the unit, meeting well the requirements of large and medium-sized mobile screening units ; Thin oil lubrication of the bearings effectively reduces their temperature and increases their lifespan. In actual production, users often report that horizontal vibrating screens and inclined vibrating screens fail to achieve the desired processing capacity, resulting in low efficiency. As important equipment in the screening industry, the screening efficiency of horizontal vibrating screens and inclined vibrating screens not only has a significant impact on the value of the products but also directly affects the efficiency of subsequent processing steps. Six measures to improve the efficiency and performance of horizontal vibratory screens and inclined vibratory screens are summarized here, in the hope of being helpful for everyone’s production. 1. Select the appropriate types of horizontal and inclined vibrating screens. Although the screening effect mainly depends on the properties of the material being screened, using different types of screening equipment for the same material can yield different screening results. For example: The screening efficiency of fixed screens is relatively low ; The screening efficiency of a vibrating screen is related to the manner in which the screen surface moves; particles on the screen surface are shaken in a direction nearly perpendicular to the screen holes, and the higher the vibration frequency, the better the screening effect ; On the surface of a shaking screen, particles mainly slide along the surface; since the shaking frequency of a shaking screen is lower than that of a vibrating screen, its screening efficiency is poorer ; Cylindrical screens have low screening efficiency due to the easy clogging of their screening surface. Furthermore, different types of vibrating screens should be selected for various applications; for example, circular vibrating screens are generally used for the preliminary screening and inspection of materials ; The classification of the crushed material is carried out using probability screens, equal-thickness screens, and large-scale vibrating screens ; Linear vibrating screens are used for material dehydration and desliming ; For removing sand and mud from materials, using a probabilistic equal-thickness screen yields better results. In actual production, it is also necessary to, depending on the specific circumstances and while meeting the requirements regarding product particle size, choose non-metallic screen surfaces with larger screen hole sizes, a greater effective screening area, and a higher porosity, as well as appropriate screen hole shapes, in order to improve the ability to pass particles through the screen and enhance work efficiency. 2. Reasonably select motors for horizontal and inclined vibrating screens, and adjust the excitation force. The proper selection of vibrating motors is one of the key factors affecting the performance of vibrating screens; meanwhile, the magnitude of the excitation force is the core factor influencing the productivity of vibrating screens. 1) Selection of vibration motors: As the vibration source for vibrating screens, vibration motors should possess advantages such as reasonable design, simple and compact structure, high excitation efficiency, energy conservation, and ease of installation and commissioning. The selection of vibration motors involves specific parameters such as operating frequency, maximum excitation force, and power. First, select the operating frequency and excitation force; the speed of the vibration motor should be close to the operating frequency ; The maximum excitation force must be within the range of the combined excitation force of the selected motor; thereafter, the power of the vibration motor is chosen based on the operating frequency and the maximum excitation force. 2) Adjustment of excitation force: The productivity of vibrating screens is related to the excitation force in an exponential manner; an increase in the excitation force leads to a rapid increase in productivity, while the clogging rate decreases sharply as the excitation force increases. The excitation force also has a certain impact on the screening efficiency and crushing rate, and their variation patterns are both wave-shaped: when the excitation force is too low, the screening efficiency and crushing rate are poor ; When the excitation force is too large, it increases the friction between the eccentric weights at both ends of the vibratory motor’s shaft. Under high-speed rotation, this can easily damage the motor and shorten its service life. Therefore, it is crucial to properly adjust the magnitude of the excitation force. The excitation force of a vibration motor is the centrifugal inertial force generated by a high-speed rotating eccentric mass. Changing the eccentricity, and thereby changing the amplitude of the excitation force, makes it possible to regulate the excitation force. 3. Improve the movement pattern of the screen surface in horizontal vibratory screens and inclined vibratory screens. The movement pattern of the screen surface has a significant impact on the efficiency of vibratory screens. The ideal movement pattern of the screen surface should be as follows: 1) The vertical amplitude at the feed end of the screen surface should be greater than that at the discharge end. This is because the feed end has a large vertical amplitude, which enables the thicker material at that end to be effectively stratified; meanwhile, the inclination helps to spread the excess material at that end rapidly toward the center of the sieve surface, allowing the fine particles to pass through the sieve as they are stratified in a relatively thin layer, thereby increasing the actual usable area of the sieve surface. By the time the material reaches the discharge end, it is already layered. At this point, only a small vertical amplitude is required to ensure good conditions for the fine particles to pass through the sieve; too large a vertical amplitude, on the other hand, disrupts the conditions necessary for the fine particles to pass through the sieve. 2) Along the length of the screen surface, starting from the feed end, the material velocity should decrease. This is because the movement speed of the material decreases, but the material layer maintains a constant thickness across the entire screen surface, allowing fine particles to pass through the screen over a relatively larger area, thereby increasing the actual usable area of the screen. At the same time, the amount of material that passes through the screen along its length becomes more uniform, enabling the screen to fully utilize its screening capacity. The equal-thickness screens and dual-frequency vibrating screens developed in recent years have overcome the drawbacks of conventional vibrating screens—namely, a constant amplitude across the entire screen surface and low unit screening capacity. They feature a greater amplitude at the feed end, while the discharge end maintains the same amplitude as that of conventional vibrating screens, thereby improving work efficiency. 4. Both horizontal vibrating screens and inclined vibrating screens use screens made of non-metallic materials. Non-metallic screen materials have the following advantages: 1) Improved screening efficiency. Its screening efficiency is about 20% higher than that of metal screens. 2) Good wear resistance and long service life. Its average lifespan is more than 25 times that of metal screens. 3) Reduces installation time and improves equipment uptime. Thanks to the **prolonged service life** of non-metallic screen meshes, the frequency of screen surface replacements is reduced; as a result, the equipment operating rate increases by 15% compared to that of conventional metal screens. 4) Reduce noise and improve the working environment. During operation, in addition to resonating with the screen box, the wire mesh also undergoes some vibrations; this phenomenon becomes more pronounced after wear. Coupled with the rigid impact of materials against the box surface and the vibrations of other components, this results in relatively high noise levels. The screen made of non-metallic material forms a single unit as a whole, providing a certain degree of buffering effect that can reduce noise by around 20 dB(A). 5. Horizontal vibrating screens and inclined vibrating screens use multi-feed methods. Ordinary vibrating screens typically use a single feed method: after the material is supplied to the screen surface, most of it that is smaller than the separation size passes through the screen holes at the feed end and becomes the product below the screen. In the area of the screen surface that is 1/3 to 1/2 away from the discharge end, aside from continuing to perform a certain screening function, it mainly serves to transport the material, resulting in low efficiency in utilizing the screen surface. If multiple feed methods are used, it is equivalent to increasing the width of the screening surface and reducing the thickness of the material layer fed onto it. This facilitates quick contact of fine particles with the screening surface and their passage through the sieve holes. At the same time, it makes full use of the screening surface, reducing the unnecessary distance that coarse particles have to travel, thereby improving the efficiency of the screening process. 6. Strengthen the operation management of horizontal vibrating screens and inclined vibrating screens. Operation and maintenance also have a certain impact on the performance of vibrating screens. To ensure the efficient operation of a vibrating screen, it is necessary to follow the operating procedures carefully: the feeding must be uniform, continuous, and in appropriate amounts, so as to ensure a even distribution of the material across the entire width of the screen. This helps fine particles to pass through the screen, resulting in a higher processing capacity and screening efficiency.

Submit a Project

**Looking for Chemical Technology, Equipment & Solutions?** No Registration Required Broader Platform Exposure | Global Chemical Service Provider Connections

Submit Request — Free Consultation

Disclaimer

This is an automated machine translation of the original thread. Some technical terms may have inaccuracies; the original text shall prevail. Click "View Original" at the top right to access the source page, which supports IP-based automatic real-time language translation. Please watch out for contact details and sales inducements to prevent fraud. All content and translations are for reference only, representing solely the poster's personal views. For enquiries, email service@hcbbs.com.