Thread Content
This post was last edited by shrien on 2015-8-10 at 11:04. For decades, it has been predicted that the use of mechanical switches will gradually disappear, with sensors often regarded as their main alternative technology. Has this change begun to occur? And to what extent is it widespread? This article will explore these questions. As a historically significant electromechanical device, switches have existed since the Industrial Revolution. Various switches have been designed to work better in conjunction with electromechanical devices. These devices include relays, solenoids, motors, incandescent lamps, and hundreds of other products available on the market today. A sensor, on the other hand, is an electronic device designed to work in conjunction with electronic components such as integrated circuits, transistors, and diodes. As microprocessor technology becomes more widely used, power grids, electrical appliances, power tools, air conditioning systems, and consumer electronics all employ sensing technologies that can be easily connected to microprocessors. Switches are widely used due to their high reliability. In machine-to-machine interface applications, switches often serve as sensing devices to indicate the open or closed state of doors or covers; position sensing is another common application, where switches can help detect the position of cams and levers; in horizontal level sensing within production lines, switches are used to indicate whether cabinets or storage containers are full, at a low level, or empty, thereby improving efficiency in production. Sensors can be used in switching applications; as their functions improve, they are becoming alternatives to some older electromechanical switching technologies. Using sensors to detect objects can help reduce the size of devices. An increasing number of sensing technologies are emerging, with presence, level, and position sensors rapidly replacing traditional electromechanical switches. At the same time, as microprocessor-based control technology becomes increasingly widespread in various applications, capacitive, inductive, ultrasonic, optical, and Hall effect sensors are finding broader applications in smart grids and consumer markets. Touch sensing technology is also becoming increasingly popular. Touch screens are quite common; they provide operators with a visual interface for direct communication with a large number of devices. Computer touchscreens are widely used in ATMs, computer monitors (replacing mice in some applications), automotive and building safety systems, smart grids, mobile phones, and PDAs, among others. The expanding range of applications for various sensors will further stimulate demand for this technology. Although sensors possess the aforementioned characteristics of miniaturization and simplicity, they also exhibit weaknesses in terms of durability in many applications; it is not easy to use sensors as a direct replacement for electromechanical switches. A key advantage of a switch is that it can handle higher electrical loads than sensors, which is crucial for electromechanical devices with high inductive or resistive loads. Sensors usually require secondary switching devices such as relays in order to handle the aforementioned types of loads. Switches are usually two-wire devices that do not require external power. Sensors generally have at least a three-wire configuration, and they need to be redesigned in order to replace switches. In all applications, switches supply power, while sensors require power. Obviously, switches and sensors have their respective advantages; therefore, a careful evaluation is needed for specific applications to determine which one is the most suitable. Cost is important; any improvement in technology often requires consideration of cost factors. Many types of switches cost well under $1 each. Although the price of sensors is falling, it remains well above $1. There are other considerations as well: using sensors in place of switches may require tasks that incur additional costs, such as redesigning the products and circuits, adding secondary switching components to enable compatibility with the sensors, modifying production lines, and training operators. All of these factors can increase the cost of transitioning from switches to sensors. However, the cost of switches is also a factor that changes. Environmental regulations are becoming increasingly strict, and cadmium used in the manufacture of contacts is subject to tighter restrictions in many markets due to its environmental pollution. The costs associated with redesigning switches to meet environmental requirements, along with rising raw material costs for producing switches, may narrow the cost gap between switches and sensors. Is cost important? Yes, indeed it is. If the cost of transitioning from switches to sensors is too high, manufacturers may prevent such a transition in order to achieve higher profit margins. As demand for electronically controlled products grows in the market, and the cost of new sensor products decreases, manufacturers may use sensors more frequently to replace switches. Improved electrical design, the use of fewer sensors to replace multiple switches, and enhanced reliability of sensors in new applications will open up new opportunities for the sensor market. The claim that sensors will completely replace switches is somewhat unrealistic; at least not in the near future, as switches still outperform sensors in many applications. However, with improvements in sensor technology, sensors may perform more reliably in environments where switches are prone to failure. Innovation activities are giving rise to new applications and technologies; we will see how the switch and sensor markets will adapt better to market demands. Original title: Sensors make electrical switching devices smarter