Thread Content
A dual-chamber balanced container is a cleverly designed water level measurement device for steam drums that possesses certain self-compensation capabilities. Its main structure is shown in Figure 1. Above the reference cup, there is an annular funnel-shaped structure that divides the entire two-chamber balance vessel into upper and lower sections; it is called a two-chamber balance vessel to distinguish it from a single-chamber balance vessel. For ease of explanation, the various main components are named condenser chamber, reference cup, overflow chamber, and communicating vessel, based on their functional characteristics. Additionally, the water level measurement device in the dual-chamber balance vessel is referred to simply as the vessel in this text. 3.2. Under ideal conditions in the condenser, saturated water vapor coming from the steam drum releases its latent heat of vaporization as it passes through this area, resulting in saturated condensate that is supplied to the reference cup and subsequent stages for use. 3.3. The reference cup serves to collect the condensate water from the condenser chamber, and to channel the pressure generated by this condensate water out of the container, to the positive pressure side of the differential pressure measuring instrument – the differential pressure transmitter (hereinafter referred to as the transmitter). The volume of the reference cup is limited; once it is filled with condensate, the excess flows over into the overflow chamber. Since the height of the rim of the reference cup is fixed, it is called a reference cup. 3.4. Overflow Chamber: The overflow chamber occupies most of the space within the container. Its main function is to collect the condensed water that overflows from the reference cup, and to discharge this condensed water into the boiler downcomer. During this flow process, it heats and stores heat throughout the container, ensuring that the temperature remains consistent with that in the steam drum. Under normal conditions, due to the dynamic action of the fluid in the boiler downcomer, there is basically no water accumulation in the overflow chamber, or only a small amount. 3.5. Connected vessel – a reverse T-shaped connected vessel, with one end of its horizontal section connected to the steam drum and the other end connected to the negative pressure side of the transmitter. Undoubtedly, its main function is to transmit the pressure generated by the dynamic water level in the drum to the negative pressure side of the transmitter, and to compare it with the (reference) pressure on the positive pressure side in order to determine the water level in the drum. It is designed in an inverted T shape to ensure that the fluid in the container has a certain degree of fluidity, thereby preventing freezing in the pipelines between the steam drums during winter. The temperature of the fluid inside the communicating vessel is likely to differ from that in the drum, resulting in a liquid level that is different from that in the drum; however, due to the self-balancing effect of the fluid, this has no impact on the measurement of the drum’s liquid level. 3.6. Calculation of differential pressure: As explained earlier, the temperature of the fluid in the condenser chamber, the reference cup, and the pressure guide tubes located at the bottom of these components is equal to the temperature of the fluid in the steam drum; that is, γw = γ’w and γs = γ’s. Therefore, it is not difficult to obtain the differential pressure output by the container. This article takes the two-chamber balance vessel with a measurement range of ±300 mm, used in the DG670-13.73-8A type boilers manufactured by Dongfang Boiler Factory, as an example (as shown in Figure 1). As can be seen from Figure 1, the pressure output on the positive-pressure side of the container equals the total static pressure above the horizontal level of the reference cup opening, plus the pressure of the condensed water in the vertical section between the reference cup opening and the horizontal axis of the L-shaped pressure guide tube, plus the pressure generated by the fluid in the vertical pipe segment outside the container, located between the horizontal axis of the L-shaped pressure guide tube and the horizontal axis of the communicating vessel. Obviously, the pressure in the last part is such that, since the medium there is at rest and located far from the container, its density should be the density at ambient temperature. Therefore, P = PJ + 320 γw (580 – 320) γc. Here, P is the pressure at the positive pressure side of the container; γw is the density of the medium inside the container (γw = γ`w); γc is the density of water at the ambient temperature. PJ represents the total static pressure above the reference level of the cup. The pressure on the negative pressure side equals the total static pressure above the horizontal level of the reference cup, plus the pressure generated by saturated water vapor between that horizontal level and the vapor-liquid interface in the drum, plus the pressure generated by saturated water between the vapor-liquid interface and the horizontal axis of the connecting vessel. That is, P– = PJ + (580 – hw) γshwγw. Here, P– is the pressure at the negative pressure side of the container; hw is the vertical distance from the vapor-liquid interface to the centerline of the horizontal tube in the connecting vessel; γs is the density of saturated water vapor in the drum. Thus, the differential pressure ΔP = P – P– = 320 γw + 260 γc – (580 – hw) γs – hwγw. In other words, ΔP = 260 γc + 320 γw – 580 γs – (γw – γs)hw. It should be noted that γc, the density of water at the ambient temperature mentioned in equation (1), generally changes with the seasons, and such changes can affect the accuracy of drum water level measurements. For the vessel in this example, when the ambient temperature rises from 25°C to 50°C, the effect of the change in density on the differential pressure is –2.3 mm of water column; after compensation by the compensation system, the impact on the final drum water level will be between 2.3 and 5.5 mm. Under normal circumstances, such errors can be ignored; in other words, the temperature here can be considered constant. However, to minimize errors, the temperature here must be determined properly. The temperature can be determined following this principle: choose the higher value rather than the lower one, taking into account factors such as the local climate and winter heating requirements. For example, if the ambient temperature here typically ranges from 0 to 50°C throughout the year with an average of 25°C, then the temperature here can be set at 35°C. This is because the rate of change of water density increases as temperature rises; choosing a higher temperature will result in the environmental temperature changes having a lesser impact on the entire system. For the container in this example, when the temperature rises from 0°C to 25°C, the change in temperature has an effect of only about 1 mm on the final result of the measurement system; whereas an increase in the ambient temperature from 25°C to 50°C results in an effect ranging from 2.3 to 5.5 mm. Therefore, the temperature should be set high rather than low. 4. Operating characteristics of dual-chamber balance vessels The operating characteristics of these vessels are very important for the drum water level measurement and compensation systems; understanding such characteristics helps users to apply them effectively and master the skills involved in their use. The density of saturated water and saturated water vapor at various pressures can be found in the \"Density Tables for Saturated Water and Saturated Water Vapor\". By substituting the drum water levels of 0, ±50, ±100 mm, etc., into equation (1), a series of differential pressures output by the container can be obtained, as shown in Table 1 below, \"Reference Table for the Inherent Compensation Characteristics of Dual-Chamber Balanced Containers\". Table 1 shows the operating characteristics of the two-chamber equilibrium vessel. As can be seen from Table 1, the differential pressure output by the container at each water level changes differently as pressure varies (due to changes in the saturated vapor and water densities). First, note the differential pressure corresponding to the 0 water level; its variation pattern is significantly different from that of other water levels, as it fluctuates only within a relatively narrow range. Since the design pressure of this container is 13.73 MPa, its fluctuation range is smaller below 14.5 MPa, staying within only ±5 mm of water column. In other words, when the water level in the drum is at 0 level, regardless of how the pressure changes, even in the absence of a compensation system, the impact on the measurement of 0 level is minimal or essentially none. Regarding other water levels, the differential pressure corresponding to a drum water level that is closer to the 0 level is less affected by pressure changes, whereas it is more affected in the opposite case. Therefore, a two-chamber balanced vessel is a drum water level measuring device with a certain self-compensation capability. Its ability in this regard lies in the fact that the higher the water level in the drum is close to the 0 level, the less affected its output differential pressure is by pressure changes; in other words, the less impact it has on the measurement of the drum’s water level. Undoubtedly, the characteristics of a container are determined by its own structure, which is why they are also referred to as inherent compensation characteristics. In Table 1, 0 MPa corresponds to two rows of differential pressure values, and the reason for this will be explained later. The reason for this characteristic of dual-chamber balance vessels lies in the fact that they are designed and manufactured with a special structure that minimizes the impact of changes in the density of steam and water on the pressure difference associated with normal operating water levels. Nevertheless, it cannot fully meet the production needs, and compensation still remains necessary. 5. Compensation System 5.1. Basic Knowledge and Concepts It can be seen from the characteristics of containers that dual-chamber balanced containers cannot fully meet the requirements of production. The reason for this is due to changes in the medium density. Therefore, certain measures must be taken to further eliminate the impact of density changes on drum water level measurement. This measure used to eliminate the effects of density variations is called compensation. The water level in the drum is accurately determined through compensation. There are generally two methods for compensating the drum water level measurement: pressure compensation and temperature compensation. The compensation effect is the same regardless of which method is used. However, there is a slight difference between them: temperature compensation can start at 0°C, whereas pressure compensation can only start at 100°C. This is because temperature can correspond one-to-one with both the saturated density and the unsaturated density at temperatures below 100°C, whereas pressure can only correspond one-to-one with the saturated density; that is, the lowest pressure of 0 MPa corresponds only to the saturated density at 100°C. Therefore, the compensation starting points corresponding to each of the compensation systems formed by these two methods are different, that is, the ranges of the differential pressure transmitters vary. This is why there are two differential pressure values corresponding to 0 MPa in Table 1 ; The previous row corresponds to temperature compensation, while the next row corresponds to pressure compensation. Obviously, temperature compensation can also start at 100°C