Among tantalum, zirconium, titanium, and Hastelloy, which one has the strongest resistance to high temperature and pressure?

Thread Content

Each material has its parameter boundaries for reliable operation. In corrosive media, the corrosion rate may double for every 10°C increase in temperature—a physical conclusion derived from the Arrhenius equation, not an empirical estimate. This issue provides an in-depth analysis of the true limits of these four materials in terms of temperature and pressure. According to the physical laws governing corrosion and temperature, in the process of electrochemical corrosion, the relationship between the corrosion rate and temperature follows the Arrhenius equation: for every increase of about 10°C in temperature, the reaction rate constant (and thus the corrosion rate) increases by approximately 1.5 to 2 times. This means that: a material with a corrosion rate of 0.1 mm/year at 30°C may have a rate of 1.0–1.6 mm/year at 70°C. A material that is “acceptable” at 60°C may become “unacceptable” at 100°C. This is why even slight changes in process parameters – such as an increase in reaction temperature from 80°C to 95°C – can push a material that was originally “still usable” into a category where it suffers rapid degradation within a few months. Source: Fontana, M.G., “Corrosion Engineering,” 3rd ed., McGraw-Hill, 1986. Chapter 9: Corrosion Rates and Prediction. In hydrochloric acid environments: material rankings as temperature increases📋 The patents held by SGL Carbon specify the material requirements for use in high-temperature hydrochloric acid conditions. U.S. Patent US 2023/0331551 A1 (SGL Carbon SE) states that for its high-pressure hydrochloric acid desorption units, the inner walls must have corrosion resistance when operating at 110°C with HCl concentrations of at least 35 wt%; tantalum or tantalum-lined columns are listed as one of the possible solutions. This parameter combination (110°C + high-concentration HCl) exceeds the upper limit of the reliable operating temperature for C-276. Source: US 2023/0331551 A1, Woltz et al., SGL Carbon SE, Oct. 2023. In sulfuric acid systems, the corrosion rate of C-276 material at high temperatures varies with temperature; data from Haynes Technical Data. Source: Haynes International, “Corrosion Resistance of Hastelloy C-276 Alloy,” Bulletin H-2095C. In contrast, the corrosion rate of tantalum does not increase significantly across this temperature-concentration range under the same conditions, remaining constant throughout