Regarding the question raised by Haiyou, should we make fun of it?
Thread Content
I’ve read a few articles recently; the professional questions raised in those posts were quite simple, and as a result some forum members responded to them in a mocking or dismissive manner. On a forum with such a high level of professionalism, many users are likely experts, but there are also beginners who, due to lack of exposure to this field in their work, have a strong desire to learn. They hope to gain something by coming here. I think that no matter what kind of questions users ask, as long as they are sincere in their desire to learn, we should offer them genuine help. We all started as beginners once, so I hope everyone will help those in need with kindness and compassion. Do you all agree with my view? I hope you’ll join the discussion. . . . . .
Sister Qingfeng, you can post this for discussion in the editorial department. Or create a debate thread! Actually, whether to tease depends on the level of interaction between the poster and the thread owner, their personalities, and their mood at that time. There are indeed serious technicians who prefer theory only and disdain to answer simple questions, doing so with contempt – and such people are not a minority ； Some forum users don’t even search for relevant posts within the forum; they post questions that have already been answered multiple times, or they post the same content in several different sections ； Some are even the type who just reach out without looking or asking their colleagues or supervisors, and post a question like, \"What do you think about this?\" Just like the pipeline ISO diagram, how is this read and what does it mean? Leaving those from other majors aside, regarding the issue of posting content within one’s own major, will it lead to being looked down upon?
Of course, the purpose of posting this is to highlight that such situations are common in technical forums; there are also cases where people argue due to language differences. I want to draw everyone’s attention to this. It’s understandable if one doesn’t feel like responding, but verbal attacks are not acceptable.
Fighting is normal too, but it depends on what the fighting is about. It is normal to have disputes over technical or management issues; one should not refrain from speaking just because of fear of arguments. Of course, those who initiate malicious attacks should be prohibited from doing so. Another factor is to consider the poster’s intent and purpose, as well as whether it is worth engaging in a discussion, in order to treat different situations differently. If the goal is simply to run ads, then editing and organizing posts according to the level of oversight is something that happens quite often, so there’s no need to go into further detail ； If you want to learn*, then the questions asked should be of some value, and they might form a series of follow-up questions. If you say you don’t know, well then it depends on what criteria are used; not knowing cannot be used as an excuse ； No matter how powerful a sea or river may be, it cannot be a universal machine that solves every problem, especially those related to copyright ； If they simply don’t want to learn, sending a message on the first day asking what this is and another message on the second day asking what that is – if you can see that they’re not learning or progressing, would you still pay attention to them? Tell him to study on his own; I don’t have time to chat with him idly. As for such people, to put it bluntly: if you don’t want to learn on your own and aren’t willing to put in the effort, then don’t stay here – I really don’t want to see you. For example, if a graduation project requires CAD files, would you scold them, ignore them, or help them?
Agreed; it seems like a simple question to you, but it might be difficult for the person asking, as they need it urgently! So it should be answered properly! If you’re at a master level and don’t want to reply or consider it beneath you to reply, then don’t reply – no one will care! There will always be enthusiastic sea friends who are willing to answer.
Just ignore him; why bother scolding him? Instead of spending time insulting him, you might as well help those whom you think deserve it. Moreover, using insults is itself a sign of poor character; by insulting others, you don’t make them more sensible – instead, it lowers your own status, doesn’t it?
It’s two-way; there are some things that need to be criticized, like texts like this, “You guys from HaiChuan, your management team.” . . Just like in the valves and fittings section, there was a post about resource sharing – it was just one page long – and I shared it. People from all over started criticizing me; isn’t that asking for trouble? There are also those who rate avatars, post spam replies, and start arguments after leaving comments. . .
I’ll move the post to your forum; you can create a voting format with options for both sides so that everyone can vote on it
Sister Qingfeng, it can’t be changed. Try it yourself; you need to choose “Start a debate”” ； Voting is another way to post. .
I agree with you; everyone has a starting point. It’s best to treat others with sincerity!
It definitely shouldn’t be done; after all, there are specialized areas of expertise~~