Thread Content
Dear experts in this industry, I’ve run into a problem with the heat exchanger recently and would like to share it with you all for discussion. I hope you can help identify the cause and offer some suggestions. Thank you! The heat exchanger is a spiral-wound tube heat exchanger (brand: Shandong Nuowei, NERVE), used to heat circulating water with steam; this circulating water is then used for cleaning containers. Specific operating parameters: Heat source: 0.6 MPa saturated steam; Refrigerant: pure water at 25°C, heated to 88°C. Requirements: Total water volume is 30 t, circulation rate is 100 t/h, with a design time of 1.5 hours to reach the specified temperature. Problem description: It can be heated to over 70 degrees in about 1 hour, while it takes 2–3 hours to raise the temperature from over 70 degrees to 88°C. The heating time at higher temperatures is too long – 2 hours longer than designed – and the actual maximum heating temperature reached is 86°C. Troubleshooting: 1. The technologies of both parties have been used to thoroughly review the initial design, and both the heat exchange area and flow rate meet the requirements of the operating conditions ; 2. During normal production, the requirements can be fully met, and the overall heat load is no problem ; 3. The installation method has been verified to be correct: steam enters from above and exits from below, while circulating water enters from below and exits from above; vertical installation ; 4. The heat source and interface pipe sizes are satisfactory and meet the requirements ; 5. The total water volume should be added at 30t, so that the circulation volume meets the requirements ; 6. The circulating water is fresh water ; Empty the pipeline before heating ; 7. The circulating water is purified water, so there is no issue of scale formation that could reduce heat exchange efficiency; moreover, it is cleaned after each use, which eliminates the risks of scale formation and blockages. 8. During normal production, the bypass valve of the steam trap is in a slightly open state. 9. The heating time required the first time to reach the specified temperature is 3.5 hours, while it takes a little over two hours for the second heating cycle to reach the same temperature; this rules out equipment-related issues as the cause. An overview shows that steam traps play a role in preventing steam from entering and draining water in steam heating systems; by selecting the appropriate steam trap, steam heating equipment can achieve its highest efficiency. To achieve the most optimal results, it is necessary to have a comprehensive understanding of the operating performance and characteristics of various types of steam traps. A steam trap must be able to “identify” steam and condensate in order to function as a vapor barrier and drain. “The detection of steam and condensate is based on three principles: density difference, temperature difference, and phase change. Thus, three types of steam traps were manufactured based on three principles: they are classified as mechanical, thermostatic, and thermodynamic types. Working principle: The steam trap is installed between the steam heating equipment and the condensate return header. When turned on, the barrel is at the bottom and the valve is fully open. After entering the steam trap, the condensate flows to the bottom of the tank, filling the valve body and submerging it entirely; thereafter, the condensate is discharged to the return water header through the fully open valve. Steam also enters the steam trap from the bottom of the tank, occupying the upper part of the tank and creating buoyancy. The barrel rises slowly, gradually moving the lever toward the valve seat until the valve is completely closed. Air and carbon dioxide gas gather at the top of the steam trap through the exhaust holes in the barrel. The steam discharged from the vent holes condenses due to the heat dissipation by the steam trap. When the incoming condensed water begins to fill the tank, the tank starts to exert a pulling force on the lever. As the condensation level continues to rise, the force generated increases until it is sufficient to overcome the pressure difference and open the valve. As the steam trap valve begins to open, the pressure difference acting on the valve disc decreases. The barrel body will drop rapidly, causing the valve to open fully. The non-condensable gases accumulated at the top of the steam trap are discharged first, followed by the condensed water. As the water flows out of the tank, it carries the dirt with it and out through the drain valve. As the condensate is discharged, steam begins to flow back into the drain valve, and a new cycle starts. Devices that use and utilize steam only require steam. Condensate water is inevitably generated within such equipment; this condensate becomes a harmful fluid, and it also contains air and other non-condensable gases, which are causes of equipment failures and performance degradation. Under such circumstances, the most important functions of a steam trap are as follows: (1) it can quickly remove the condensed water that is generated. (2) Prevent steam leakage. (3) Remove air and other non-condensable gases. After discussing it with the client, almost all aspects have been taken into account. Fortunately, there is no impact during operation now; it was just that the heating time at the beginning was too long. But in the interest of being responsible to our customers and to avoid such situations in the future, I would appreciate it if someone could offer some advice. Thank you!
It takes 2–3 hours to heat from over 70 degrees to 88°C; the heating time at high temperatures is quite long, which is normal. With the heat exchange area, heat source, flow rate, and so on remaining unchanged, it will take a longer time to raise the temperature from over 70 degrees to 88°C, as the temperature difference between the two media is relatively smaller, resulting in reduced heat exchange efficiency and speed.
This heat exchanger typically has insufficient efficiency; the process specification calls for reaching the desired temperature in 1.5 hours, but it actually takes more than 2 hours. When the heat source’s stability is poor, it is due to the low efficiency of the heat exchanger
Check what heat transfer power is specified in the equipment calculation sheet?
Generally, in the design calculations of heat exchange equipment, the heat load refers to the value under steady-state conditions; if the time required for the heat exchange to reach a steady state is involved, then transient calculations are necessary. Transient heat transfer calculations are more complex than steady-state calculations, as the actual heat exchange power changes nonlinearly with temperature. It is generally estimated based on experience. There are many factors that affect the time it takes for heat transfer to reach a steady state. Heating power, heat exchange area, tube arrangement, and so on. Your current situation is that the transient heating time during startup is insufficient. If meeting the time requirement is necessary, it might be necessary to add a device for auxiliary heating at startup!